The State, the Government, and You
Q1. “Every democracy is a republic.” Is this statement true or false? Explain.
Answer:
This statement is false.
Explanation:
- In a democracy, people elect their representatives.
- In a republic, the head of the state is elected, not a king or queen.
- Some countries like the UK are democratic but have a king or queen, so they are not republics.
- Therefore, every democracy is not a republic.
Example:
- India → Democratic Republic
- UK → Democratic but not a republic
Q2. Give two reasons why decentralisation is important in India.
Answer:
- Better decision-making:
Local governments understand local problems like water supply, roads, and schools better. - More participation:
People can directly take part in decisions that affect their daily lives.
Q3. Student Council as a Mini-Parliament
(a) Should only the council president make all decisions or should power be shared?
Answer:
Power should be shared among all members because:
- It allows discussion and debate
- It prevents misuse of power
- It represents everyone’s views
(b) Should the student council decide food or language?
Answer:
No, because:
- These are personal choices
- Making such rules would violate students’ freedom
(c) What can go wrong if no one questions the council?
Answer:
- Decisions may become unfair
- Power may be misused
- Students’ rights may be ignored
Q4. Questions Related to India’s Democracy
(a) Should Parliament be the most powerful institution? Why/Why not?
Answer:
No. Power should be shared among:
- Parliament
- Executive
- Judiciary
This system of checks and balances prevents misuse of power.
(b) Should Parliament make any law even if it affects rights?
Answer:
No.
- Parliament must follow the Constitution
- Laws cannot violate Fundamental Rights
(c) What could go wrong if lawmaking has no limits?
Answer:
- Unfair laws may be made
- Minority rights may be ignored
- Democracy may be weakened
(d) Who is more powerful – Parliament or Supreme Court?
Answer:
Neither is more powerful.
- Parliament makes laws
- Supreme Court checks whether laws follow the Constitution
Both are important and balance each other.
Q5. Interaction of Parents with Government
Sample Answer (Students can write):
My parents interacted with the government in the following ways:
|
Activity |
Level of Government |
|
Aadhaar correction |
Central |
|
Electricity bill issue |
State |
|
Road repair complaint |
Local |
|
School admission |
State |
|
Ration card |
State |
Comments
Post a Comment